Is it good
that dispensing money on space travel is less popular than it was during the
space race? Or do we need the inspiration
that space programs can bring? Is this
just a natural result of our nature as a “questing species”? Should Slovakia get more involved and
invested in the EU space program? What do you think about the space ark?
Hi. Welcome to the blog for my IB English B class at Jur Hronec High School in Bratislava, Slovakia. Below you will find links to other websites and discussion questions. My students are required to comment on one of these postings every month and also respond to each other's comments. Feel free to add your two bits, but be aware that all comments are monitored before being posted.
Wednesday, February 28, 2024
Spacing out...
You say disorder, I say diversity. Let‘s call the whole thing off.
How attracted
are you to the idea of neurodiversity?
Is this just another form of modern relativism? When can labels be helpful and when are they
harmful in terms of describing human brains/personalities? Do we lose something important when we drop
the concept of normal/abnormal?
Not a labor of love
Mercenaries
have often been despised since they kill others for money rather than because
of their beliefs or values (such as a desire to defend ones homeland or ethnic group). Is it understandable to you that someone from
a poor country would make a decision to work for a foreign army? Is this a career just like any other (with
its own moral ambiguities)?
Since I’m depressed, how about if I actively work to make my/our situation worse?
I can certainly
relate to the frustration which often results from trying to help a friend
overcome depression. What are your own
experiences? What do you think about
the advice given here for dealing with this difficult situation? Do we have a duty to help people in this situation
even if there is a cost to our own happiness?
America everywhere you look
This is the last entry you can comment on for late February to mid-March.
Do you feel that American culture is dominating the world? Are other cultures being silenced or repressed as a result? What can or should be done about this? Do you agree with the author in her assertion that this cultural dominance serves US political interests? Are there any possible positive aspects to this situation?
Saturday, January 20, 2024
Would you like a placebo for your headache?
Do you trust doctors? Is it sometimes necessary to lie to a patient in order to help them more effectively? Or for researchers to lie to gain important information about human health and psychology? This is not the only article I have read which indicates that placebos are somewhat effective even if the patient is aware that they are taking a placebo. Why do you think this is the case?
Wedding Woes
Do you like
going to weddings? Are traditional weddings a good thing, or have these
traditions become too restrictive? Can
you understand why brides (and grooms) are reluctant to spend a lot of
time and money on a wedding, or maybe would like to avoid any ceremony at
all? Could the anti-bride trend help
solve these problems or is it just a scam?
Emissions for me and negative impacts for thee
Does it outrage you that the countries who are most to blame for global warming are (for the most part) not those who have to deal with its consequences? What are some of the reasons for why money which was pledged to fight the causes and effects of climate change is not used for this? What can be done about this problem? Would raising awareness help?
Focusing on the fashion and family of female politicians
Reading
about the woes of the former Finnish PM made me think about the situation of Čaputová here in Slovakia. Do you agree
with this article's claim that citizens do not have an overall bias against
female politicians? Their evidence for
this is cross-national. Might Slovakia
be an exception? What has your experience
of the media coverage of women in politics been? Should the media change how they cover female
candidates and politicians? How?
(Half) Gay Marriage
This is the last entry you can comment on for mid-January to mid-February.
This is an article about how two films (one Indian and one American) depict marriages between a gay man and a straight woman. I am aware that this sort of thing often happens in Slovakia as well, seemingly because it allows gay men to hide their homosexuality from a hostile society and also to raise a family. There are obvious problems with such arrangements of course. Could making homosexual marriage legal help? Looking at it from a different angle, can a marriage be happy without a sexual component? (You can also comment on one or both of the films and how they depict this situation if you have seen them.)
Sunday, November 26, 2023
Swift and sure
What do you
think about pop star fan groups being mobilized for political and charitable
causes? Once a star becomes famous
and influential, do they have a moral obligation to use their influence to
make the world a better place, or should they just stick to what they know
best? What about all of the politicians
like Trump or Zelenskyy who were known as entertainment celebrities and had
little political experience when they came to power?
Tracing the Romani Studies learning curve
Are Slovaks
learning enough about national minorities in the current educational
system? To what extent can education
about Roma help to create better mutual understanding and undermine
racism? What do you think about how Ort
describes Romani studies and its theory of knowledge (arrggh, TOK...) and
research methods? Would you be attracted
to this field of study? What do you
think about Ort’s critical stance toward the concepts of “adapting” “integration”
and “harmony”?
The power of politicians, protestors, or the pen?
Is politician
a dirty word in Slovakia like it is in Vietnam or Pakistan? Should it be?
To what extent can anger help or hinder us in pushing for political
change? Do we have solo protestors in
Slovakia? Do we need more of them? Is a journalist’s vocation to tell (their)
stories? Which role is the most virtuous or most effective: elected official,
activist or journalist?
Degrees of Uselessness?
This piece
is a bit longer than the others, but there are lots of interesting
thoughts to tackle here. What is the
point of studying the humanities (like literature, culture or philosophy)? Is too much or too little emphasis placed on
them in the IB program? In the Slovak
educational system? Should they receive less state funding than
STEMs since they are supposedly less practical?
Are governments right to be wary of their influence? Can they help make democracy stronger?
Nicking Cave’s style
This is the
last entry you can comment on for mid-November to mid-December
What do you
think about how Nick Cave describes the creative process? Is he right about the limitations and dangers
of AI technologies like chatGPT? Can
chatGPT be used as a creative tool, or is it destined to always produce something
inauthentic and derivative?